プログラマブルフロー保護の導入：Magic Transit顧客向けカスタムDDoS軽減ロジック

We're proud to introduce Programmable Flow Protection: a system designed to let Magic Transit customers implement their own custom DDoS mitigation logic and deploy it across Cloudflare’s global network. This enables precise, stateful mitigation for custom and proprietary protocols built on UDP. It is engineered to provide the highest possible level of customization and flexibility to mitigate DDoS attacks of any scale.

Programmable Flow Protection is currently in beta and available to all Magic Transit Enterprise customers for an additional cost.

Programmable Flow Protection is customizable

Our existing DDoS mitigation systems have been designed to understand and protect popular, well-known protocols from DDoS attacks. For example, our Advanced TCP Protection system uses specific known characteristics about the TCP protocol to issue challenges and establish a client’s legitimacy. Similarly, our Advanced DNS Protection builds a per-customer profile of DNS queries to mitigate DNS attacks. Our generic DDoS mitigation platform also understands common patterns across a variety of other well known protocols, including NTP, RDP, SIP, and many others.

However, custom or proprietary UDP protocols have always been a challenge for Cloudflare’s DDoS mitigation systems because our systems do not have the relevant protocol knowledge to make intelligent decisions to pass or drop traffic.

Programmable Flow Protection addresses this gap. Now, customers can write their own eBPF program that defines what “good” and “bad” packets are and how to deal with them. Cloudflare then runs the program across our entire global network. The program can choose to either drop or challenge “bad” packets, preventing them from reaching the customer’s origin.

The problem of UDP-based attacks

UDP is a connectionless transport layer protocol. Unlike TCP, UDP has no handshake or stateful connections. It does not promise that packets will arrive in order or exactly once. UDP instead prioritizes speed and simplicity, and is therefore well-suited for online gaming, VoIP, video streaming, and any other use case where the application requires real-time communication between clients and servers.

Our DDoS mitigation systems have always been able to detect and mitigate attacks against well-known protocols built on top of UDP. For example, the standard DNS protocol is built on UDP, and each DNS packet has a well-known structure. If we see a DNS packet, we know how to interpret it. That makes it easier for us to detect and drop DNS-based attacks.

Unfortunately, if we don’t understand the protocol inside a UDP packet’s payload, our DDoS mitigation systems have limited options available at mitigation time. If an attacker sends a large flood of UDP traffic that does not match any known patterns or protocols, Cloudflare can either entirely block or apply a rate limit to the destination IP and port combination. This is a crude “last line of defense” that is only intended to keep the rest of the customer’s network online, and it can be painful in a couple ways.

First, a block or a generic rate limit does not distinguish good traffic from bad, which means these mitigations will likely cause legitimate clients to experience lag or connection loss — doing the attacker’s job for them! Second, a generic rate limit can be too strict or too lax depending on the customer. For example, a customer who expects to receive 1Gbps of legitimate traffic probably needs more aggressive rate limiting compared to a customer who expects to receive 25Gbps of legitimate traffic.

image

An illustration of UDP packet contents. A user can define a valid payload and reject traffic that doesn’t match the defined pattern.

The Programmable Flow Protection platform was built to address this problem by allowing our customers to dictate what “good” versus “bad” traffic actually looks like. Many of our customers use custom or proprietary UDP protocols that we do not understand — and now we don’t have to.

How Programmable Flow Protection works

In previous blog posts, we’ve described how “flowtrackd”, our stateful network layer DDoS mitigation system, protects Magic Transit users from complex TCP and DNS attacks. We’ve also described how we use Linux technologies like XDP and eBPF to efficiently mitigate common types of large scale DDoS attacks.

Programmable Flow Protection combines these technologies in a novel way. With Programmable Flow Protection, a customer can write their own eBPF program that decides whether to pass, drop, or challenge individual packets based on arbitrary logic. A customer can upload the program to Cloudflare, and Cloudflare will execute it on every packet destined to their network. Programs are executed in userspace, not kernel space, which allows Cloudflare the flexibility to support a variety of customers and use cases on the platform without compromising security. Programmable Flow Protection programs run after all of Cloudflare’s existing DDoS mitigations, so users still benefit from our standard security protections.

There are many similarities between an XDP eBPF program loaded into the Linux kernel and an eBPF program running on the Programmable Flow Protection platform. Both types of programs are compiled down to BPF bytecode. They are both run through a “verifier” to ensure memory safety and verify program termination. They are also executed in a fast, lightweight VM to provide isolation and stability.

However, eBPF programs loaded into the Linux kernel make use of many Linux-specific “helper functions” to integrate with the network stack, maintain state between program executions, and emit packets to network devices. Programmable Flow Protection offers the same functionality whenever a customer chooses, but with a different API tailored specifically to implement DDoS mitigations. For example, we’ve built helper functions to store state about clients between program executions, perform cryptographic validation, and emit challenge packets to clients. With these helper functions, a developer can use the power of the Cloudflare platform to protect their own network.

Combining customer knowledge with Cloudflare’s network

Let’s step through an example to illustrate how a customer’s protocol-specific knowledge can be combined with Cloudflare’s network to create powerful mitigations.

Say a customer hosts an online gaming server on UDP port 207. The game engine uses a proprietary application header that is specific to the game. Cloudflare has no knowledge of the structure or contents of the application header. The customer gets hit by DDoS attacks that overwhelm the game server and players report lag in gameplay. The attack traffic comes from highly randomized source IPs and ports, and the payload data appears to be random as well.

To mitigate the attack, the customer can use their knowledge of the application header and deploy a Programmable Flow Protection program to check a packet’s validity. In this example, the application header contains a token that is unique to the gaming protocol. The customer can therefore write a program to extract the last byte of the token. The program passes all packets with the correct value present and drops all other traffic:

#include <linux/ip.h>

#include <linux/udp.h>

#include <arpa/inet.h>

#include "cf_ebpf_defs.h"

#include "cf_ebpf_helper.h"

// Custom application header

struct apphdr {

uint8_t version;

uint16_t length; // Length of the variable-length token

uint8_t token[0]; // Variable-length token

} __attribute__((packed));

uint64_t

cf_ebpf_main(void *state)

{

struct cf_ebpf_generic_ctx *ctx = state;

struct cf_ebpf_parsed_headers headers;

struct cf_ebpf_packet_data *p;

// Parse the packet headers with provided helper function

if (parse_packet_data(ctx, &p, &headers) != 0) {

return CF_EBPF_DROP;

}

// Drop packets not destined to port 207

struct udphdr *udp_hdr = (struct udphdr *)headers.udp;

if (ntohs(udp_hdr->dest) != 207) {

return CF_EBPF_DROP;

}

// Get application header from UDP payload

struct apphdr *app = (struct apphdr *)(udp_hdr + 1);

if ((uint8_t *)(app + 1) > headers.data_end) {

return CF_EBPF_DROP;

}

// Perform memory checks to satisfy the verifier

// and access the token safely

if ((uint8_t *)(app->token + token_len) > headers.data_end) {

return CF_EBPF_DROP;

}

// Check the last byte of the token against expected value

uint8_t *last_byte = app->token + token_len - 1;

if (*last_byte != 0xCF) {

return CF_EBPF_DROP;

}

return CF_EBPF_PASS;

}

An eBPF program to filter packets according to a value in the application header.

This program leverages application-specific information to create a more targeted mitigation than Cloudflare is capable of crafting on its own. Customers can now combine their proprietary knowledge with the capacity of Cloudflare’s global network to absorb and mitigate massive attacks better than ever before.

Going beyond firewalls: stateful tracking and challenges

Many pattern checks, like the one performed in the example above, can be accomplished with traditional firewalls. However, programs provide useful primitives that are not available in firewalls, including variables, conditional execution, loops, and procedure calls. But what really sets Programmable Flow Protection apart from other solutions is its ability to statefully track flows and challenge clients to prove they are real. A common type of attack that showcases these abilities is a replay attack.

image

In a replay attack, an attacker repeatedly sends packets that were valid at some point, and therefore conform to expected patterns of the traffic, but are no longer valid in the application’s current context. For example, the attacker could record some of their valid gameplay traffic and use a script to duplicate and transmit the same traffic at a very high rate.

With Programmable Flow Protection, a user can deploy a program that challenges suspicious clients and drops scripted traffic. We can extend our original example as follows:

#include <linux/ip.h>

#include <linux/udp.h>

#include <arpa/inet.h>

#include "cf_ebpf_defs.h"

#include "cf_ebpf_helper.h"

uint64_t

cf_ebpf_main(void *state)

{

// ...

// Get the status of this source IP (statefully tracked)

uint8_t status;

if (cf_ebpf_get_source_ip_status(&status) != 0) {

return CF_EBPF_DROP;

}

switch (status) {

case NONE:

// Issue a custom challenge to this source IP

issue_challenge();

cf_ebpf_set_source_ip_status(CHALLENGED);

return CF_EBPF_DROP;

case CHALLENGED:

// Check if this packet passes the challenge

// with custom logic

if (verify_challenge()) {

cf_ebpf_set_source_ip_status(VERIFIED);

return CF_EBPF_PASS;

} else {

cf_ebpf_set_source_ip_status(BLOCKED);

return CF_EBPF_DROP;

}

case VERIFIED:

// This source IP has passed the challenge

return CF_EBPF_PASS;

case BLOCKED:

// This source IP has been blocked

return CF_EBPF_DROP;

default:

return CF_EBPF_PASS;

}

return CF_EBPF_PASS;

}

An eBPF program to challenge UDP connections and statefully manage connections. This example has been simplified for illustration purposes.

The program statefully tracks the source IP addresses it has seen and emits a packet with a cryptographic challenge back to unknown clients. A legitimate client running a valid gaming client is able to correctly solve the challenge and respond with proof, but the attacker’s script is not. Traffic from the attacker is marked as “blocked” and subsequent packets are dropped.

With these new abilities, customers can statefully track flows and make sure only real, verified clients can send traffic to their origin servers. Although we have focused the example on gaming, the potential use cases for this technology extend to any UDP-based protocol.

Get started today

We’re excited to offer the Programmable Flow Protection feature to Magic Transit Enterprise customers. Talk to your account manager to learn more about how you can enable Programmable Flow Protection to help keep your infrastructure safe.

We’re still in active development of the platform, and we’re excited to see what our users build next. If you are not yet a Cloudflare customer, let us know if you’d like to protect your network with Cloudflare. Join our Programmable Flow Protection Discord channel to chat with us about this feature.